Did not played it but maybe reviews are about balance, great over the top actions and HARD Stop to ok-ish characters, story, ok open world, back to AMAZING actions. wolfensteins had REALY good gunplay and action but equally good i think cutscenes, story, little tarrantino style montages was nice to look at and enjoy before you came back to the action. Borderlands is Great lootershooter but people didnt mind the story, have a few laughs and start shooting again. If there is a good illusion of progression you are more likely to be tricked into a gameloop. games are games, more often then not you are reapeting the same scheme of actions for hours, its a designers job to make that ilussion beliveable.